SpaceX’s successful recovery of its Starship rocket last weekend cleared a major hurdle on NASA’s path to the Moon, opening up possibilities for higher launch rates and an all-important, long-delayed orbital refueling demo next year. //
Early next year, SpaceX plans to bring online a second Starship launch site at Kennedy Space Center, Florida. A second Starship factory is also under construction at Kennedy, joining SpaceX’s existing SpaceX production line at Starbase, Texas. With two launch sites, SpaceX will have the pieces in place to take the next leap with Starship. //
Rocketfan1138 Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
2y
183
Subscriptor
Taboobat said:
I truly have failed to grasp why there are so many damn launches required to get to the moon now compared to the 60s. Are we just hauling more mass this time? Have we changed to a less efficient fuel? Is Starship really just small? 20 launches just to get the go seems bonkers, so many opportunities for a significant failure.
Yes, ultimately, we are hauling more mass this time.
Apollo put two guys on the surface of the Moon. In the longest Apollo mission, Apollo 17 (which was also the last Apollo mission) they spent about three days actually on the Moon.
The goal of Artemis, at least in theory, is to eventually do a lot more on the Moon than just land a couple of guys on the Moon for a day or three. The goal is to eventually have a permanent base on the Moon, where people--more than two people at a time--will presumably stay for weeks or months, and where there will be a permanent human presence that will last for years and even decades. (There have been human beings at the South Pole for 70 years now. In the summer, there are 150 people down there, but even in the winter there's close to 50 people--and Amundsen-Scott isn't the only base in Antarctica, either.)
Also, we would like for all of this to be cheaper than Apollo was. Apollo probably cost over a quarter of a trillion dollars in 2020's money. Artemis II showed that there is actually still a fairly considerable public interest in human spaceflight, when NASA can get through to people that it's actually happening. ("Whoa, some people just went to the Moon again! Cool!") But we as a country are really not prepared to spend Apollo-like money on space exploration--truth is, even during the days of Apollo, the program was always controversial and never had anything like universal public support. ("Whitey on the Moon" and all that.)
All of which necessitates doing things differently than we did for Apollo. Apollo was a monumental achievement, but just redoing Apollo would be pointless. If we are going to do this again, we need to do it better. //
stefan_lec Ars Scholae Palatinae
5y
1,143
Subscriptor
Taboobat said:
I truly have failed to grasp why there are so many damn launches required to get to the moon now compared to the 60s. Are we just hauling more mass this time? Have we changed to a less efficient fuel? Is Starship really just small? 20 launches just to get the go seems bonkers, so many opportunities for a significant failure.
Because distributed launch is cheaper and easier (with modern control systems), and capable of much, much more mission-wise. That last part was known all the way back in the 50’s and 60’s. They went with a single launcher to get a very minimal mission done as quickly as possible, at the cost of ending up with a dead-end architecture that couldn’t really scale past those basic missions.
Add reusabililty and mass manufacturing (well, “mass” compared to typical rockets anyway), and it’s not even debatable which is better.
With regards to risk, a Saturn V/Apollo launch involved three stages, two completely different spacecraft, many different engine designs, and multiple independent fuels (kerolox, hydrolox, and hypergolic). That is an extremely complex, Rube Goldberg system.
SpaceX’s proposal uses one single engine design for almost everything (possibly a second one for HLS landing, but that’s still a bit unclear). They launch simple variants of the same dirt-cheap upper stage a whole bunch of times, and reuse almost all of that design for the lander. That is MUCH simpler in engineering terms, with many, many less independent systems to test. And it’s insanely more capable, while being multiple orders of magnitude cheaper.
The only reason nasa never pursued distributed launch before now was politics, multiple companies have proposed it over the years. SpaceX just happened to be pursuing it with their own money anyway, which backed everyone into a corner when it turned out they were the only ones who could do a lander for the price Congress was willing to pay at the time. //
aq42 Ars Centurion
10y
351
PsychoArs said:
What I'm hearing is... not fit for purpose.
I'm not a rocket scientist but it still sounds massively inefficient. If the vehicle isn't right for the job...
What's the job? If it's just getting two crew from low lunar orbit to the surface, supporting them there for four days, and getting them back up to LLO, then yes. If you're going to treat it as the first stage in the development of a lunar base where you'll want more crew on the surface for longer, with rovers, habitats, scientific experiments etc leading eventually to a permanent presence, that changes the picture.